Tuesday, 12 April 2011

Wiki: a critical analysis

http://yr12anatomy101.wikispaces.com/home

Plus:

·         Below is a comprehensive a list of benefits outlined in our readings and sourced from wiki.org:

Open - Should a page be found to be incomplete or poorly organized, any reader can edit it as they see fit.

Incremental - Pages can cite other pages, including pages that have not been written yet.

Organic - The structure and text content of the site are open to editing and evolution.

Universal - The mechanisms of editing and organizing are the same as those of writing so that any writer is automatically an editor and organizer.

Observable - Activity within the site can be watched and reviewed by any other visitor to the site.

Convergent - Duplication can be discouraged or removed by finding and citing similar or related content.

Trust - This is the most important thing in a wiki. Trust the people, trust the process, enable trust-building. Everyone controls and checks the content. Wiki relies on the assumption that most readers have good intentions. But see: AssumeGoodFaithLimitations

Fun - Everybody can contribute; nobody has to.

Sharing - of information, knowledge, experience, ideas, views...

Interaction - This enables guest interaction.

Collaboration - A good collaboration tool, both synchronously and asynchronously.

Social Networks - Its power for supporting collaboration is great.

Minus:
  • Requires stringent moderation
  • Care must be taken to ensure valuable information is not lost
  • Cost of extra features – basic package (free) offers limited accessibility
  • Incorrect information may be taught
  • May cause arguments/unrest amongst peers

 Interesting:
  • Are students at a level of maturity where they can be trusted to responsibly handle such a technology?
  • May potentially be hogged by teacher pet types.

1 comment:

  1. Wow. Literally just spent an hour at 12.30am trying to upload and edit that post. I ended up getting stuck in some weird bug and had to keep re-formatting in word until it posted properly.
    ...and then spent another 5mins trying to work out which account to sign into and what my password was just so I could post this comment. ARGHH!!

    Minus:
    Technology can be a severe drain on time

    ReplyDelete